ESPLER Project Elaborates on Why It's Refiling Legal Challenge

ESPLER Project Elaborates on Why It's Refiling Legal Challenge

LOS ANGELES — ESPLER Project today explained in detail why it changed its legal strategy in its challenge over California’s anti-prostitution law and won’t pursue its case to the U.S. Supreme Court.

ESPLER Project for the past several years has challenged the legality of California Penal Code 647(b), claiming it is unconstitutional. It filed a suit against the state of the California, seeking an injunction over its enforcement, but lost its challenge at the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

Today, industry attorney Louis Sirkin told XBIZ and other reporters that ESPLER Project’s case should be litigated in state court. Sirkin is one of several attorneys that have worked on ESPLER Project’s decision to challenge Penal Code 647 (b).

“This may be the place to go,” Sirkin said. “We can start over. We've learned some lessons, and we've got an addition to the substantive due process we can bring into the right of privacy that California provides, and so we thought that that would be a better battle ground.”

Sirkin noted that there's no specific wording in the U.S. Constitution and the Bill of Rights that gives each citizen an "inalienable right" to pursue and obtain privacy.

“There is in California,” said Sirkin, noting that he and ESPLER Project’s board “put a lot of discussion in” a change of legal strategy using alternative channels. “I think we made the right decision.”

“All along we had been looking at the California constitution,” Sirkin said. “You have Article 1, Section 1, that has a constitutional right of privacy, which doesn't exist in the U.S.”

Sirkin, who was joined by ESPLER Project’s Maxine Doogan and Domina Elle, said that a major reason to drop the challenge before U.S. Supreme Court was that Justice Anthony Kennedy was stepping down.

“I think we evaluated the situation with the Supreme Court and the strategy changed a bit on the announcement of the resignation of Justice Kennedy that came at the end of June,” Sirkin said.

“We were disappointed that the 9th Circuit missed an opportunity to declare that the Constitution protects the right of consenting adults to engage in private sexual activity,” Sirkin said. “We were also disappointed that their decision relied on a 1998 case (IDK Inc. v. Clark County), which has since been clearly superseded by Lawrence v. Texas, the 2003 Supreme Court case which struck down sodomy laws nationwide and established a constitutional right to sexual privacy.

“You know, without [Kennedy] it might have been difficult,” Sirkin said. “We would have an adverse decision by the Supreme Court … and if they didn't grant the petition for certiorari [to take the case], people always would have made negative inferences from that.”

Sirkin said that there ESPLER Project, known to many also as the Erotic Service Providers Legal, Education and Research Project, hasn’t decided on a timeline for its next step — to file another lawsuit at California superior court.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Niki Media Acquires BritSexCash

Production studio Niki Media BV has acquired affiliate program BritSexCash.

Agatha Vega: From Venezuela to Venerated Vixen

Agatha Vega was brought up in a small neighborhood in Caracas, Venezuela, a city known for its urban dangers. Yet despite her surroundings, she says, she had very positive experiences growing up. With various relatives living in close proximity, she was always able to enjoy the company of her family.

Kylie LeBeau Makes Her Hookup Hotshot Debut

Kylie LeBeau has made her Hookup Hotshot (HUHS) debut alongside studio honcho Bryan Gozzling.

Vixen Media Group Extends Exclusive Contract With Dan Damage

Vixen Media Group has renewed its exclusive contract with Dan Damage.

FSC Warns of Nude Photography Site Falsely Claiming Affiliation With Organization

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) published a statement Friday warning of a nude art photography website fraudulently claiming to be associated with the industry trade organization.

Evil Angel to Drop JD's 'Transgressive 24'

Evil Angel debuts the 24th volume of director JD’s “Transgressive.”

Connie Perignon Stars in Latest From Brazzers

Connie Perignon stars with Jordi El Nino Polla in the latest release from Brazzers, titled "The Sneaky Masseur."

Sinatra Monroe Has 'A Classy Affair' in Ricky's Room

Sinatra Monroe stars in the latest release from Ricky's Room, titled "A Classy Affair."

MojoHost Reaffirms Commitment to Adult Industry Amid Project 2025 Implications

In the wake of Tuesday's election and amid concerns about the possible ramifications for the adult industry, MojoHost President Brad Mitchell has releases a statement addressing Project 2025 and the future of the industy.

TeamSkeet Debuts New Series 'PervMassage'

Fanta Sie stars with Erick Everhard in the first episode of the new TeamSkeet series, “PervMassage."

Show More