U.K. Insurer Loses .XXX UDRP Arbitration Case

PRAGUE — There have been more than 20 UDRP cases filed against .XXX website operators since the top-level domain's launch, and for the first time a complainant has lost its cybersquatting case in mediation.

On Tuesday, a Czech arbitration court rejected U.K. insurance company BGL Group Ltd.'s dispute over CompareTheMarket.xxx, which is inactive.

BGL Group argued in its UDRP case that the .XXX  site at issue infringes on its online properties — CompareTheMarket.com and CompareTheMarket.co.uk., as well as CompareTheMeerkat.com, a marketing site that introduces an "anthropomorphized" cartoon meerkat character.

The insurance company, which said that the sites have been online and functioning for as many as seven years, said that the .XXX domain name was registered in bad faith because the U.K. registrant, Jon Watkins, seeks only to take unfair advantage of its brand.

"No legitimate interest is being pursued through the domain," the insurance company wrote in its Uniform Domain-Name Dispute-Resolution Policy, or UDRP, petition."The sole motivation is to benefit from BGL's established brand."

But arbitrator Mike Rodenbaugh rejected BGL's complaint, ruling that CompareTheMarket.xxx's operator didn't register the domain in bad faith.

"Complainant states that the domain is 'completely inactive,' he ruled. "Complainant does not show that respondent tried to sell the domain to complainant, has registered other infringing names, or otherwise has tried to profit from the domain or cause any other harm to complainant.

"Respondent is not shown to have had prior UDRP cases in which he has been an unsuccessful defendant. Clearly, 'compare the market' could relate to myriad different types of markets and myriad different comparisons within each one, as demonstrated by a simple web search.

"Trademark rights are defined in scope, and do not give rise to transfer of generic or descriptive domains via the UDRP unless bad faith use of the domain is proved. Inactive non-use is clearly an insufficient indicator of bad faith; there must be something more."  

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Pineapple Support Taps Reagan Foxx as Brand Ambassador

Pineapple Support has named Reagan Foxx as its newest brand ambassador.

Randy Denmark Launches New Paysite

Producer and content creator Randy Denmark has launched his new membership site, RandyDenmark.com, through MyMember.site.

Alabama Senate Committee Approves Porn Filtering, App Store-Based AV Bills

The Alabama state Senate’s Children and Youth Health Committee on Thursday approved two bills intended to prevent minors from accessing adult content online, one aimed at device manufacturers and the other aimed at app store providers.

Sen. Mike Lee Renews Push for Federal AV Legislation

Republican Sen. Mike Lee of Utah on Wednesday reintroduced a federal age verification bill that has twice previously failed to make it through Congress.

South Dakota Governor Signs AV Law With Criminal Charges

South Dakota Governor Larry Rhoden has signed into law a bill imposing criminal charges on sites that fail to perform age verification of users when providing access to adult content.

UK Pornography Review Recommends Banning 'Extreme' Content

The “pornography review” initiated under the conservative government of former U.K. Prime Minister Rishi Sunak is soon expected to present its recommendations, which according to a BBC report will include banning any adult content deemed “degrading, violent and misogynistic.”

Malaysian Government Urges Tech Companies to Continue Porn Crackdown

Communications Minister Fahmi Fadzil has asked all social media and online messaging platforms with at least 8 million users to register as application service providers beginning this year, in an effort to monitor and prevent pornography on such sites.

SceneLocker Extends Closed Beta Test for Creators

Content creator cloud storage company SceneLocker has extended its closed beta test.

Ms. Magazine Exposes Anti-LGBTQ+ Effects of AV Laws

Ms. magazine on Tuesday published an article examining how state age verification laws, promoted as a way to protect children online, are being used to censor LGBTQ+ and abortion-related content.

Zuzana Designs Marks 20-Year Anniversary

Web design and marketing firm Zuzana Designs is celebrating its 20th anniversary.

Show More