Stagliano, McDonald Discuss Kozinski 'Kerfuffle'

LOS ANGELES — In the ongoing "Dust-Up" between adult producer John Stagliano and Pepperdine law professor Barry McDonald in the Los Angeles Times' Opinion section, the topic Tuesday involved what the Times called the "kerfuffle" over Judge Alex Kozinski, his website, his recusal from the Ira Isaacs obscenity case, and what that might suggest about legal objectivity and popular ideas about porn.

In his remarks, Stagliano asked "What makes porn uniquely unacceptable?" Framing the question as a difference between those who accept pornography and those who disdain it, Stagliano said, "It would have been so refreshing if Kozinski had said, 'Yeah, I like to look at a racy pictures sometimes; so what? Mind your own business.' But that would be asking too much of a public figure."

Stagliano continued by pointing out that public opinion turned against Kozinski as soon as it was known that he "[had] any interest in this vile thing known as porn" and asked rhetorically if a judge who raced cars as a hobby could serve in traffic court.

McDonald followed Stagliano's remarks by observing "when something happens that would give a person sufficient reason to question the impartiality of a judge in a case, that judge is obligated to recuse herself or himself. This standard not only looks to whether the judge would actually be biased in a case but also whether an incident might create an appearance of bias to a reasonable person regardless of whether or not the judge was actually biased."

Praising Kozinski for his recusal, McDonald cited Kozinski's "long, distinguished career [as a] very able jurist" and observes that because Kozinski could be perceived to have prejudice in an obscenity case, he did the right thing to recuse himself.

"Thus — and I'm sorry to say, John — all of your musings regarding the sexual rights of public officials are largely irrelevant to the recusal question," McDonald wrote.

McDonald followed that the problem of obscenity enforcement lies with Supreme Court standards that posit "pornography so lewd and offensive that it is obscene deserves no 1st Amendment protection," suggesting that the problem with judicial objectivity about porn may be based on such Supreme Court rulings.

The series, which will continue through Thursday, can be read on the Los Angeles Times website.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Wendy Raine Fronts 'Mamma Mia' Parody From MYLF

Wendy Raine stars with Eva Nyx and Quinton James in a “Mamma Mia” parody from MYLF, titled “Memories Cumming to My Mind.”

Briella Coley Makes Her Evil Angel Debut

Briella Coley has made her debut for Evil Angel alongside director/performer Richard Mann.

Jasmine Sherni Takes the Spotlight in 2-Part Brazzers Release

Jasmine Sherni stars in the two-part Brazzers scene titled “TroubleMakerzz.”

Ofcom: Age Assurance Going Live Across 'Thousands' of Porn Sites

U.K. communications regulator Ofcom said in a statement Thursday that providers of online pornography are implementing age assurance across “thousands of sites” accessible in the U.K., in response to Ofcom’s Online Safety Act (OSA) enforcement program.

Linda Lan Performs 1st Anal, Headlines Jonni Darkko's 2nd 'POV Anal Sluts'

Linda Lan performs her first anal scene and toplines director Jonni Darkko’s sequel to “POV Anal Sluts,” from Evil Angel.

XBIZ Miami's Host Hotel Sold Out, General Registration Now Open

Guest rooms at XBIZ Miami’s exclusive conference venue, Nautilus Sonesta Miami Beach hotel in South Beach, are now completely sold out.

Leana Lovings, Aria Banks Front Latest From Reality Kings

Leana Lovings and Aria Banks star in the latest release from Reality Kings, titled "Synchronized Scissoring."

Penthouse Names Lennon Elizabeth April's 'Pet of the Month'

Penthouse Magazine has named model Lennon Elizabeth as Pet of the Month for April.

Bella Spark, Kelly Collins Star in Finale of VMG Cross-Site Feature 'Bang and Burn'

Bella Spark and Kelly Collins star with Vixen Media Group exclusive Jason Luv in the final installment of the cross-site spy feature "Bang and Burn."

Jade Kimiko, Cecelia Taylor Headline 'Women Seeking Women 199'

Jade Kimiko and Cecelia Taylor topline “Women Seeking Women 199” from Girlfriends Films.

Show More