India Obscenity Arrest Sparks Global Uproar

LOS ANGELES — With more American companies increasingly turning to India for e-commerce opportunities, the arrest of an eBay unit’s executive over a porn video for sale on his company’s website has caused an international stir.

Caught in the middle of the sex scandal is Avnish Bajaj, the Indian-born American executive who heads Baazee.com, where the clip was put up for sale.

But of greater concern to many in the online adult and mainstream business community is Bajaj’s arrest under the ambiguous Information Technology Act of 2000, which makes it a criminal offense to “publish, transmit, or cause to publish any information in electronic form, which is obscene.”

Bajaj was arrested last week and freed after posting bail Tuesday. While granting bail, the New Delhi High Court told Bajaj he couldn’t leave India without permission. If convicted, Bajaj could be jailed for up to five years; be fined 100,000 rupees, or about $2,300; or both.

The arrest stems from a listing on Baazee of a video depicting oral sex between a teenage boy and girl at one of India’s top schools —The Delhi Public School — that was captured on cellphone and later burned onto CDs.

Lasting 2 minutes and 37 seconds, the video clip has since traveled all over the country and overseas through the Internet. It didn’t draw much attention until an engineering student at a prestigious Indian college listed it for sale on Baazee, which has 1 million registered users.

Now the 17-year-old girl who performed in front of the camera has been sent to Canada by her parents, and the boy, 17, is now in a juvenile detention center until Jan. 4, when he’s expected to end questioning by India authorities.

Though public transmission and sale of pornography in India is a crime, possession and viewing is not. Pornographic videos are available in most Indian cities, where there is a flourishing underground trade.

Pawan Duggal, a cyber law expert, told the Times of India that Bajaj’s arrest has serious implications, especially when Internet usage in the country is rapidly growing and foreign investors are increasingly looking to India for business opportunities.

“Ultimately we have to see a bigger picture,” Duggal said. “We want to increase Internet penetration.”

Kiran Karnik, president of India’s National Association of Software and Service Companies, agreed — somewhat.

“There should be no inhibition of e-commerce,” Karnik said. “But companies must respect the laws of the land respecting pornography.”

Duggal, however, said changes need to be made to the obscenity laws to plug some loopholes that drag Internet companies into legal problems.

“I believe the government is in the process of plugging them,” he said. “The law needs to be more industry friendly and more pragmatic.”

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Open Mind AI Seeks Inclusion in EU's AI Debate

New European industry initiative Open Mind AI has penned a letter asking EU authorities to include adult companies and creators in ongoing discussions on setting up a legal framework for AI content.

UK Labour Government Confirms it Will Continue Baroness-Led 'Porn Review'

The U.K. Labour government of Prime Minister Keir Starmer has confirmed it will continue the controversial full review of British pornography laws ordered by former Tory Prime Minister Rishi Sunak in July 2023.

SWR Data Survey Probes Concerns About Political Attacks on Industry

SWR Data, an adult-sector market research firm led by industry veterans Mike Stabile and MelRose Michaels, has released data from its upcoming 2024 State of the Creator report, illustrating creators’ concerns about political attacks on the industry.

FSC Urges SCOTUS to Strike Down 'Unconstitutional' Texas Age Verification Law

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) urged the U.S. Supreme Court through a brief filed Monday to strike down Texas’ age verification law as unconstitutional.

Japanese Manga Industry Hit by Credit Card Companies' Anti-Porn Restrictions

Japanese manga retailers are reporting pressure from multinational credit card companies — many based in the U.S. and targeted by anti-porn religious conservatives — to censor their content if they wish to maintain their current payment processing arrangements.

Netherlands Government Continues Porn Probe Following Abuse Allegations

The Dutch government plans to continue investigating the local porn industry in the Netherlands, following a series of abuse allegations involving photographer and self-styled “model scout” Daniël van der W.

Australian Government's Social Media Access Proposal Endorses Porn-Stigmatizing Report

The Australian Labor government led by Prime Minister Albanese recently announced its intention to introduce legislation this year “to enforce a minimum age for access to social media and other relevant digital platforms,” stating the upcoming proposal would be based on a recent report that uses stigmatizing language to characterize all adult content.

Federal Judge Blocks Utah's Social Media Filter Law

A federal judge in Utah has blocked the state’s controversial new Minor Protection in Social Media Act, which was set to go into effect Oct. 1.

Mashable Probes Reactions to Project 2025 Among Performers Across Political Spectrum

Tech news site Mashable published an article Tuesday surveying opinions among adult performers across the political spectrum regarding Project 2025, the conservative initiative for a presidential transition that includes a call to criminalize the production and distribution of pornography.

Time Magazine Profiles ECP's Solomon Friedman

Time magazine published on Monday a profile of Ethical Capital Partners (ECP) VP of Compliance Solomon Friedman.

Show More