Appeals Court Upholds Dismissal of FSC's Utah AV Suit

Appeals Court Upholds Dismissal of FSC's Utah AV Suit

DENVER — The United States Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit on Tuesday affirmed a district court’s motion to dismiss Free Speech Coalition v. Anderson, the industry trade association’s challenge to Utah’s age verification law.

In a statement, FSC noted that the court’s decision to reject its appeal was not a ruling on whether the state’s age verification mandate is constitutional. Rather, two of the court’s three justices rejected FSC’s attempt to bring suit against Utah’s attorney general and commissioner of public safety as public officials who, FSC argued, are closely tied to implementation and enforcement of the law. The two-to-one majority ruled that those officials are not responsible for enforcement of the law, and therefore cannot be sued by FSC.

As XBIZ reported, FSC filed its appeal last year, after a Utah judge granted the state’s motion to dismiss the organization’s challenge to SB 287, Utah’s age verification law, which went into effect in January 2023. At the time, FSC noted that the law “requires sites to verify identity through a non-existent state digital ID, or to partner with data brokers to otherwise verify age and identity of all visitors,” citing serious privacy concerns about the legislation, and contended that it is unconstitutional.

FSC opted to combat the law via a pre-enforcement challenge because while SB 287 creates civil liability for adult content platforms, it does not empower state officials to proactively file suit against sites alleged to have violated the law, and instead it outsources such actions to private citizens in Utah. Therefore, the law’s constitutionality cannot be directly challenged in court until private citizens take legal action against sites.

Industry Reactions

When FSC announced its decision to appeal, in August 2023, FSC Executive Director Alison Boden called this tactic “an end-run around the First Amendment.”

In Tuesday’s FSC statement, Boden said, “These laws were designed to be difficult to challenge and designed to have a chilling effect on our First Amendment rights. We will continue the fight to hold the state accountable for the laws it has passed.”

The chilling effect Boden warned about became evident months before the 2023 district court ruling against FSC, when Pornhub decided to block its site in Utah. 

Since then, SB 287 has served as a model for similar legislation in other states, as lawmakers seek ways to shut down adult content online while skirting constitutional challenges. If the 10th Circuit’s decision becomes precedent, that could severely hamper the ability of FSC and other free speech groups to oppose such laws.

Industry attorney Lawrence Walters, of Walters Law Group, told XBIZ that the 10th Circuit decision is “disappointing but not unexpected.”

“The Eleventh Amendment generally provides immunity to the states from being sued without their permission,” Walters explained. “This type of ‘sovereign immunity’ is subject to an important exception carved out by the U.S. Supreme Court in Ex parte Young, which allows plaintiffs to sue state officials who are responsible for enforcing unconstitutional laws.

“However, lawmakers in Utah cynically sought to frustrate judicial review of the constitutionality of its age verification law by allowing enforcement only by private parties and not state officials such as the attorney general,” Walters added. “In this way, the state politicians hoped to create a threat of enforcement while avoiding the consequences of enacting an unconstitutional law.

“Fortunately, the U.S. Supreme Court is considering a challenge to the Texas age verification law,” Walters noted. “This will likely determine whether any of these recent spate of state AV laws are consistent with the First, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments.”

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

BranditScan Names Subgirl Newest Brand Ambassador

BranditScan has named content creator Subgirl its newest brand ambassador.

Arcom Reports Age Verification Enforcement Actions Against 5 Adult Sites

French media regulator Arcom released a statement Tuesday detailing recent actions to enforce age verification rules as set forth under France’s Security and Regulation of the Digital Space (SREN) law.

Pineapple Support, Clips4Sale to Host Performers' Partners Support Group

Pineapple Support and Clips4Sale are hosting a free online support group for partners and family members of adult industry professionals.

FSC Mourns the Loss of Board Director Emeritus Mark Kernes

Free Speech Coalition has released a statement regarding the passing of Board Director Emeritus Mark Kernes.

Alexa Creed Launches New Paysite

Creator Alexa Creed has launched a new membership site through MyMember.site.

Choice Talent Management Launches Fan Platform 'ChoiceFilmz'

Choice Talent Management CEO Chris Crisco has launched a new fan platform called ChoiceFilmz.

Dredd to Launch Official Site

Dredd has announced his new website OfficialDreddXXX.com, launching April 20.

New Pleasure Product Review Site 'ToyChats' Launches

ToyChats.com, a pleasure product review and discussion site, has officially launched.

AEBN Reveals Jade Venus as Top Trans Star for Q1 of 2025

AEBN has named its top trans stars for the first quarter of 2025, with Jade Venus landing atop the leaderboard.

SexLikeReal Debuts 'AI Passthrough' Feature

SexLikeReal has introduced an AI Passthrough for video editing during VR livestreaming.

Show More