5th Circuit Hears Arguments in Texas Age Verification Challenge

5th Circuit Hears Arguments in Texas Age Verification Challenge

AUSTIN, Texas — A three-judge panel of the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday heard arguments regarding the injunction against enforcement of Texas’ controversial age verification law, which mandates that adult websites post anti-porn propaganda.

Texas authorities asked the panel to lift the injunction, which was obtained on Aug. 31 by Free Speech Coalition (FSC) and other plaintiffs. HB 1181 was passed by the Texas legislature with bipartisan support in May and was scheduled to go into effect Sept. 1.

As XBIZ reported, on Sept. 21 the 5th Circuit judges issued an administrative stay of the injunction in a two-sentence ruling that offered no details or explanations.

The injunction — issued by Senior U.S. District Judge David Ezra, a Ronald Reagan appointee — blocks the Texas attorney general from enforcing the Republican-authored anti-porn age verification law while the case is litigated.

Judge Ezra “agreed with the plaintiffs that HB 1181 violates the First Amendment by forcing websites to speak Texas’ preferred messages — the health advisories that he determined were ‘somewhat deceptive’ because the state had not shown its Health and Human Services Commission had made medical findings to back the claims,” Courthouse News reported.

Judge Ezra’s reasoning, which mentioned Section 230 protections, also questioned Texas’ approach to age verification technologies, pointing out the risk of accidental disclosures, hacks and leaks.

On Wednesday, Texas Assistant AG John Ramsey claimed Judge Ezra “misunderstood how age verification works.”

Representing website operators who were among the plaintiffs who originally sued for the injunction, attorney Derek Shaffer cited Supreme Court precedent that he said “established that HB 1181 is subject to strict scrutiny,” Courthouse News Reported, adding that the strict scrutiny standard applies in cases where “laws infringe on fundamental rights and requires legislation to be narrowly tailored and the least restrictive means to further a compelling government interest.”

Shaffer also appealed to the standard that struck down the Child Online Protection Act of 1998. In that case, Courthouse News reported, the U.S. Supreme Court “specifically named content filtering as a least restrictive alternative to the anti-obscenity measures and noted that Texas lawmakers had provided no explanation as to why they had considered filtering and found it wanting.”

Content filtering, Shaffer added, “puts the responsibility where it should be, in the home and on parents.”

The three U.S. Circuit judges — George W. Bush appointee Jennifer Walker Elrod, and Ronald Reagan appointees Jerry Smith and Patrick Higginbotham — did not say when they would rule on Texas’ appeal.

FSC Executive Director Alison Boden told XBIZ, “We are optimistic that the 5th Circuit will uphold the district court judge’s well-reasoned ruling that HB 1181 is unconstitutional and should be prevented from going into effect in Texas.”

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

BranditScan Names Subgirl Newest Brand Ambassador

BranditScan has named content creator Subgirl its newest brand ambassador.

Arcom Reports Age Verification Enforcement Actions Against 5 Adult Sites

French media regulator Arcom released a statement Tuesday detailing recent actions to enforce age verification rules as set forth under France’s Security and Regulation of the Digital Space (SREN) law.

Pineapple Support, Clips4Sale to Host Performers' Partners Support Group

Pineapple Support and Clips4Sale are hosting a free online support group for partners and family members of adult industry professionals.

FSC Mourns the Loss of Board Director Emeritus Mark Kernes

Free Speech Coalition has released a statement regarding the passing of Board Director Emeritus Mark Kernes.

Alexa Creed Launches New Paysite

Creator Alexa Creed has launched a new membership site through MyMember.site.

Choice Talent Management Launches Fan Platform 'ChoiceFilmz'

Choice Talent Management CEO Chris Crisco has launched a new fan platform called ChoiceFilmz.

Dredd to Launch Official Site

Dredd has announced his new website OfficialDreddXXX.com, launching April 20.

New Pleasure Product Review Site 'ToyChats' Launches

ToyChats.com, a pleasure product review and discussion site, has officially launched.

AEBN Reveals Jade Venus as Top Trans Star for Q1 of 2025

AEBN has named its top trans stars for the first quarter of 2025, with Jade Venus landing atop the leaderboard.

SexLikeReal Debuts 'AI Passthrough' Feature

SexLikeReal has introduced an AI Passthrough for video editing during VR livestreaming.

Show More