5th Circuit Gives Go Ahead to Controversial Texas Social Media Liability Law

5th Circuit Gives Go Ahead to Controversial Texas Social Media Liability Law

AUSTIN — A three-judge appeals panel ruled today that an extremely controversial new Texas law making online platforms liable for “viewpoint discrimination” can go into effect immediately.

The Fifth Circuit appeals panel, with jurisdiction over Texas, stayed a previous district court injunction that had put enforcement of Republican-masterminded state legislation HB 20 on hold.

The decision was communicated this afternoon without any explanation as to the court’s reasoning and with two of the judges remaining anonymous.

During a hearing on Monday, “the jurists appeared to struggle with basic tech concepts, including whether Twitter counts as a website,” tech news site Protocol reported today.

The decision is “a win for conservative critics of the current interpretation of tech law, which underlies the operations of social media platforms such as Twitter and Facebook,” Protocol continued. “Two tech trade groups that count the Big Tech companies as members had sued Texas over the law.”

Issues of content moderation, Section 230 immunity and free speech have raised the level of concern about laws such as Texas’ HB 20, as well as a similar Florida bill seeking to “punish private companies for their views and treatment of content” when such treatment is alleged to violate the First Amendment, Protocol reported.

The new law opens the way for lawsuits against online platforms accused of "viewpoint discrimination," an ill-defined term with dubious legal standing. It is mostly used by conservatives and the U.S. right wing, who claim they are being censored on social media — though some of the same politicians and right-wing activists advocating against what they call "corporate" censorship also demand a return to state-driven censorship of sexual expression via obscenity prosecutions, and consider LGBTQ+ content to be "pornography."

“Despite no prior history of courts and lawmakers treating social media as ‘common carriers’ the way phone companies are, and the clear Supreme Court precedent arguing against government interference with internet content, some conservatives have increasingly argued for treating platforms that host user-generated content similarly,” Protocol observed.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

European Industry Initiative Open Mind AI Asks EU to Be Included in AI Legislation Debate

New European industry initiative Open Mind AI penned a letter asking EU authorities to include adult companies and creators in ongoing discussions on setting up a legal framework for AI content.

Canadian Law Professor: Proposed Age Verification Bill 'Will Make Things Worse'

Leading Canadian newspaper The Globe and Mail this week published an op-ed written by a legal scholar outlining fundamental issues with the Conservative-backed age verification bill currently making its way through Parliament.

UK Labour Government Confirms it Will Continue Baroness-Led 'Porn Review'

The U.K. Labour government of Prime Minister Keir Starmer has confirmed it will continue the controversial full review of British pornography laws ordered by former Tory Prime Minister Rishi Sunak in July 2023.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches for July and August

AEBN has released the top search terms for the months of July and August from its straight and gay theaters in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.

SWR Data Survey Probes Concerns About Political Attacks on Industry

SWR Data, an adult-sector market research firm led by industry veterans Mike Stabile and MelRose Michaels, has released data from its upcoming 2024 State of the Creator report, illustrating creators’ concerns about political attacks on the industry.

FSC Urges SCOTUS to Strike Down 'Unconstitutional' Texas Age Verification Law

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) urged the U.S. Supreme Court through a brief filed Monday to strike down Texas’ age verification law as unconstitutional.

Japanese Manga Industry Hit by Credit Card Companies' Anti-Porn Restrictions

Japanese manga retailers are reporting pressure from multinational credit card companies — many based in the U.S. and targeted by anti-porn religious conservatives — to censor their content if they wish to maintain their current payment processing arrangements.

Netherlands Government Continues Porn Probe Following Abuse Allegations

The Dutch government plans to continue investigating the local porn industry in the Netherlands, following a series of abuse allegations involving photographer and self-styled “model scout” Daniël van der W.

Clips4Sale Releases '20 Years of Fetish' Data Survey

Clips4Sale (C4S) has released a report based on 20 years of data and analysis to show how kink and fetish tastes have changed since the site began.

Grooby, Yanks Ink Website Management Deal

Grooby will begin managing Yanks.com under a new company, Blue.xxx.

Show More