Extreme Associates Seeks Dismissal of Obscenity Case

PITTSBURGH, Penn. — During a series of pretrial filings before its federal obscenity case goes to trial, Extreme Associates and its co-owners Robert Zicari and wife Janet Romano have filed a motion to dismiss the indictments against them. The motion was filed Jan. 31.

Zicari and Romano, better known in the adult industry as Rob Black and Lizzy Borden are seeking a dismissal of obscenity charges filed by the U.S. government in 2003 for distributing three videos via the mail and six images over the Internet — all alleged by prosecutors to be obscene material.

In a motion for dismissal filed by Extreme attorneys H. Louis Sirkin and Jennifer M. Kinsley, Extreme Associates asked that the court dismiss all pending charges on the grounds that federal obscenity statutes are unconstitutional and do not apply to the Internet.

In lieu of a dismissal, Extreme is requesting a pretrial ruling as to the applicability of the Miller test for obscenity as it relates to the content named in the indictment. The defense argues that the Miller test’s requirement that the content be taken as a whole is impossible in the context of the worldwide Internet community and that the Miller test’s reliance upon community standards to determine whether a particular work is obscene is not viable in an online environment.

“For example, the federal obscenity statutes are unworkable when applied to the Internet because they mandate that the material be taken as a whole, an impossible task for computerized content that is entirely interconnected; and that the material be judged by the contemporary community standards of the district of prosecution, equally an implausible standard when website operators cannot control the geographic areas in which their material is accessed or viewed,” Kinsley wrote.

Additionally, Extreme Associates has requested a change of venue to the Central District of California because the company did not purposefully distribute or direct allegedly obscene materials to the Western District of Pennsylvania.

The assumption that the trial must convene from where the material was sent or received does not hold true for the Internet, Sirkin wrote. Since Extreme posted material to the Internet, it was powerless to restrict access to it by geographic region. Sirkin argued that the venue should be moved to where Extreme is based because that is where the company knowingly conduct business.

Judge Gary Lancaster originally dismissed the case in January 2005, ruling that the anti-obscenity statutes were unconstitutional when applied to Extreme Associates because they violated an individual’s right to privacy.

The Justice Department appealed that ruling before the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which overruled Lancaster.

The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Extreme’s appeal from the 3rd Circuit, sending the case back to Lancaster for trial. Upon learning of the Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the case, Zicari said it was “a big fuck you.”

Black and Sirkin were unavailable to comment at press time.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Ryan Keely, Nicole Doshi Topline Latest From Sweetheart Video

Ryan Keely and Nicole Doshi headline the 19th volume of "Lesbian Adventures: Strap On Specialists" from Mile High Media's studio imprint Sweetheart Video.

Wendy Raine Fronts 'Mamma Mia' Parody From MYLF

Wendy Raine stars with Eva Nyx and Quinton James in a “Mamma Mia” parody from MYLF, titled “Memories Cumming to My Mind.”

Briella Coley Makes Her Evil Angel Debut

Briella Coley has made her debut for Evil Angel alongside director/performer Richard Mann.

Jasmine Sherni Takes the Spotlight in 2-Part Brazzers Release

Jasmine Sherni stars in the two-part Brazzers scene titled “TroubleMakerzz.”

Ofcom: Age Assurance Going Live Across 'Thousands' of Porn Sites

U.K. communications regulator Ofcom said in a statement Thursday that providers of online pornography are implementing age assurance across “thousands of sites” accessible in the U.K., in response to Ofcom’s Online Safety Act (OSA) enforcement program.

Linda Lan Performs 1st Anal, Headlines Jonni Darkko's 2nd 'POV Anal Sluts'

Linda Lan performs her first anal scene and toplines director Jonni Darkko’s sequel to “POV Anal Sluts,” from Evil Angel.

XBIZ Miami's Host Hotel Sold Out, General Registration Now Open

Guest rooms at XBIZ Miami’s exclusive conference venue, Nautilus Sonesta Miami Beach hotel in South Beach, are now completely sold out.

Leana Lovings, Aria Banks Front Latest From Reality Kings

Leana Lovings and Aria Banks star in the latest release from Reality Kings, titled "Synchronized Scissoring."

Penthouse Names Lennon Elizabeth April's 'Pet of the Month'

Penthouse Magazine has named model Lennon Elizabeth as Pet of the Month for April.

Bella Spark, Kelly Collins Star in Finale of VMG Cross-Site Feature 'Bang and Burn'

Bella Spark and Kelly Collins star with Vixen Media Group exclusive Jason Luv in the final installment of the cross-site spy feature "Bang and Burn."

Show More