Recent Convictions Challenge Miller Test Definitions

TAMPA, Fla. — Two recent obscenity convictions have furthered the confusion of the legal definition of obscenity in the U.S. courts. At the core of the recent judgments is the definition of a "community" — specifically when that community is based online.

The Paul Little (Max Hardcore) and Karen Fletcher (RedRose.com) convictions, well known within the adult industry, have also caught the attention of mainstream media. An article posted on PC World addresses the complexity of the issue and its influence on webmasters and viewers.

Max Hardcore's recent 46-month jail term and fine, as well as Karen Fletcher's probation were achieved by the DOJ by using a traditional interpretation of the 1973 Miller v. California precedent. That ruling, which states that obscenity charges must pass a three-point test, has made previous, successful obscenity convictions difficult for the courts.

One point of that test requires that the material in question must be "the average person, applying contemporary community standards would find that the work, taken as a whole, appeals to the prurient interest."

The definition of "community" in that point is now under question when the creator of material and the consumer of the product are linked only by electronic means.

Community standards would, by definition, include anyone who would have access to the questionable material. In reality, the Internet community would be defined as global.

"With a website, you can't block traffic from another location," said Jeffrey Douglas, Little's defense lawyer.

Douglas is filing an appeal of both the conviction and sentence in the Hardcore case next week.

"This appeal will be of central importance to every adult website in the world," he said.

Hardcore's sentence has troubled many in the adult industry. The implications of Karen Fletcher's conviction, however, have been cited as having the potential to be far more chilling. Her erotic writing, posted at RedRose.com has led the 56-year old to five years of probation, including six months of being stripped of her computer. Her violation of the obscenity law was stated as "using an interactive computer service to distribute obscene materials." Although there were no pictures, the text was deemed to depict sexual molestation and violence that included children.

As previously reported in XBIZ, prosecution of literary obscenity has proven to be much more difficult than explicit images. The defense of allegedly obscene literary content, however, is often more successful when considering another Miller Test requirements: that "the work, taken as a whole, lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value."

Writing has a — or attempts to create — linear, concise thought. Eric Goldman, director of the High Tech Law Institute at Santa Clara University School of Law told PC World "it's almost impossible for text to be judged obscene."

"The idea of a contemporary community standard of obscenity is an unfounded fantasy by the judges," Douglas told XBIZ. "Either we establish an Internet community standard, or we start over from scratch and sit down and try to define obscenity properly."

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Ofcom: Age Assurance Going Live Across 'Thousands' of Porn Sites

U.K. communications regulator Ofcom said in a statement Thursday that providers of online pornography are implementing age assurance across “thousands of sites” accessible in the U.K., in response to Ofcom’s Online Safety Act (OSA) enforcement program.

ASGMax Debuts 'Roleplay' AI Chat Feature

Alpha Studio Group (ASG) has introduced the ASGmax Roleplay AI chat feature.

XBIZ Miami's Host Hotel Sold Out, General Registration Now Open

Guest rooms at XBIZ Miami’s exclusive conference venue, Nautilus Sonesta Miami Beach hotel in South Beach, are now completely sold out.

Adult Industry Educational, Networking Platform 'Imperfectly You' Launches

Imperfectly You, an educational and networking platform for adult industry workers, has officially launched.

Segpay to Launch News Network for High-Risk Merchants

Segpay has announced that it will launch the Segpay News Network (SNN) on April 15.

Age Verification Watch: Patching the Holes

This roundup provides an update on the latest news and developments on the age verification front as it impacts the adult industry.

Pineapple Support to Host Autism Spectrum Support Group

Pineapple Support is hosting a free online support group for performers and creators who are, or suspect they may be, on the autism spectrum.

ImLive Launches Revamped Member Loyalty Program

Cam platform ImLive has revamped its member loyalty program.

GoFundMe Set Up for Danny Ferretti's Medical Expenses

A GoFundMe campaign has been set up for Fangear founder Danny Ferretti, who requires extensive lung surgery.

Byborg Acquires Cuties AI

Byborg Enterprises has acquired adult artificial intelligence startup Cuties AI.

Show More