opinion

Netflix's 'Money Shot' Highlights Need for 2257 Self-Certification

Netflix's 'Money Shot' Highlights Need for 2257 Self-Certification

The Netflix documentary “Money Shot: The Pornhub Story” has sparked a debate about the consequences of Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act and its impact on the adult industry, particularly in light of the negative influence that the Fight Online Sex Trafficking Act (FOSTA) has had on content creator revenue and sex worker safety. However, most recent debate on this matter overlooks a key potential solution.

In this article, we will break down Section 230 and 2257 regulations, and explore how the existing legal framework of 2257 can offer both platforms and content creators a more compliant, stable and secure environment. This overlooked approach is 2257 self-certification.

In a 2257 self-certification system, content creator platforms would still need to take reasonable steps to ensure that the records submitted by content creators are accurate and complete.

Section 230: A Tenuous Legal Shield

Section 230 is part of the 1996 Communications Decency Act. It provides online platforms with immunity from liability for content posted by third-party users, treating them as distributors rather than publishers. This has allowed platforms like Facebook, Twitter and YouTube to thrive, but has also allowed tube sites to host user-generated content without fear of legal repercussions, even when that content may violate copyright or other laws.

In 2018, FOSTA was passed. It amended Section 230 by removing liability protection for platforms that knowingly assist, facilitate or support sex trafficking — though often in vaguely interpreted ways. This significantly weakened the protections offered by Section 230, leading payment processors to withdraw their services from some adult websites and forcing content creators using those platforms to seek alternative revenue sources.

2257 Regulations: A More Solid Foundation

Section 2257, on the other hand, is a set of regulations for the adult industry established in 1988, nearly a decade before Section 230, for the express purpose of preventing the exploitation of minors in adult content.

Under 2257, adult content producers must maintain records verifying the age and identity of performers, as well as make these records available for inspection by law enforcement. Payment processors prefer working with companies that adhere to 2257 regulations, as this reduces the risk of being associated with illegal content. Studios have long enjoyed stable, secure relationships with payment processors as a result of strictly conforming to 2257 regulations.

Introducing 2257 Self-Certification

The documentary “Money Shot” suggests that FOSTA’s impact on Section 230 created a no-win situation for content creators, but it fails to mention how existing 2257 regulations could provide a solution.

If the creator platform unit of the company in the documentary had maintained an arm’s-length relationship with its tube site branch and was structured around 2257 compliance, it could have potentially avoided the consequences that ensued. Then the platform could have potentially continued operating and processing transactions, as its most well-known studio brand eventually was allowed to.

The solution lies in content creators complying with 2257 regulations themselves, through a self-certification process whereby they take on both the role of the producer who creates the content and of the custodian who maintains the records. This would help ensure the 2257 compliance of platforms and reduce liability for payment processors.

How 2257 Self-Certification Would Work

From a content creator’s perspective, the self-certification process would involve several steps to ensure compliance with 2257 regulations. Here’s an outline of how it might work:

1) Registration: When content creators register with a platform, they need to provide their legal name, date of birth and contact information. This information would be stored securely on the platform and only be accessed for 2257 compliance purposes.

2) Uploading content: When uploading a new piece of content, the creator is required to provide 2257-related information for each performer featured in the content. This information includes the relevant performer’s legal name, date of birth and a copy of their government-issued identification.

3) Self-certification: After providing the necessary information for each performer, the content creator then certifies that the information is accurate and complete. By self-certifying, the content creator takes on the role of both the producer and the custodian of records, assuming responsibility for the accuracy of the information provided.

4) Content review and approval: The platform reviews the content and the accompanying 2257 information to ensure compliance with regulations. If the platform finds any issues, it notifies the content creator and requests the necessary corrections before the content is made available to users.

5) Record-keeping: The platform securely stores the submitted 2257 records and ensures they are easily accessible in case of an audit or investigation. The platform also maintains a log of audits and compliance checks.

6) Ongoing compliance: As the content creator continues to upload new content, they follow the same procedure for each piece, ensuring all 2257 requirements are met. The platform then periodically audits a representative sample of the records to verify their accuracy and completeness.

7) Content takedown and sanctions: If any content is found to be non-compliant, the platform promptly removes it and notifies the content creator. Repeated violations could lead to sanctions, such as suspension or termination of the content creator’s account.

Responsibilities of Content Creator Platforms

In a 2257 self-certification system, content creator platforms would still need to take reasonable steps to ensure that the records submitted by content creators are accurate and complete. The determination of what constitutes “reasonable steps” will depend on the specific circumstances and practices of each content creator platform. However, some examples of reasonable steps could include:

  • Establishing clear policies and procedures for content creators to follow when creating and submitting 2257 records, including the required information and format.
  • Providing training and education for content creators on the importance of accurate and complete 2257 records, as well as the consequences of non-compliance.
  • Conducting periodic audits or spot checks of a sample of 2257 records to ensure their accuracy and completeness.
  • Implementing technical tools or software to verify the authenticity of 2257 records, such as digital signatures or blockchain technology.
  • Maintaining clear and complete documentation of all steps taken to ensure the accuracy of 2257 records, including any training, audits or technical measures implemented.

Conclusion

The documentary “Money Shot” highlights the challenges faced by content creators due to the uncertainties surrounding Section 230, yet it fails to consider the potential benefits offered by the existing 2257 regulations. Platforms can create a more stable environment for both content creators and users by embracing a 2257 self-certification model that lets content creators assume responsibility for their own compliance.

This approach mitigates risk for all parties involved, from users to content creators, platforms and payment processors, fostering a more responsible and flourishing adult industry.

Disclaimer: The author of this article is not a lawyer, and the information provided herein should not be considered legal advice. The opinions and views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions or views of their employer. Always consult a legal professional for specific advice.

Ian Paul, the chief information officer of Naughty America, is a veteran in the adult entertainment industry who pursues technology innovation, while also advocating for responsible content creation, online safety and industry-wide compliance measures.

Related:  

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

profile

VerifyMy Seeks to Provide Frictionless Online Safety, Compliance Solutions

Before founding VerifyMy, Ryan Shaw was simply looking for an age verification solution for his previous business. The ones he found, however, were too expensive, too difficult to integrate with, or failed to take into account the needs of either the businesses implementing them or the end users who would be required to interact with them.

Alejandro Freixes ·
opinion

How Adult Website Operators Can Cash in on the 'Interchange' Class Action

The Payment Card Interchange Fee Settlement resulted from a landmark antitrust lawsuit involving Visa, Mastercard and several major banks. The case centered around the interchange fees charged to merchants for processing credit and debit card transactions. These fees are set by card networks and are paid by merchants to the banks that issue the cards.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

It's Time to Rock the Vote and Make Your Voice Heard

When I worked to defeat California’s Proposition 60 in 2016, our opposition campaign was outspent nearly 10 to 1. Nevertheless, our community came together and garnered enough support and awareness to defeat that harmful, misguided piece of proposed legislation — by more than a million votes.

Siouxsie Q ·
opinion

Staying Compliant to Avoid the Takedown Shakedown

Dealing with complaints is an everyday part of doing business — and a crucial one, since not dealing with them properly can haunt your business in multiple ways. Card brand regulations require every merchant doing business online to have in place a complaint process for reporting content that may be illegal or that violates the card brand rules.

Cathy Beardsley ·
profile

WIA Profile: Patricia Ucros

Born in Bogota, Colombia, Ucros graduated from college with a degree in education. She spent three years teaching third grade, which she enjoyed a lot, before heeding her father’s advice and moving to South Florida.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

Creating Payment Redundancies to Maximize Payout Uptime

During the global CrowdStrike outage that took place toward the end of July, a flawed software update brought air travel and electronic commerce to a grinding halt worldwide. This dramatically underscores the importance of having a backup plan in place for critical infrastructure.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

The Need for Minimal Friction in Age Verification Technology

In the adult sector, robust age assurance, comprised of age verification and age estimation methods, is critical to ensuring legal compliance with ever-evolving regulations, safeguarding minors from inappropriate content and protecting the privacy of adults wishing to view adult content.

Gavin Worrall ·
opinion

Account-to-Account Payments: The New Banking Disruptor?

So much of our industry relies upon Visa and Mastercard to support consumer payments — and with that reliance comes increased scrutiny by both brands. From a compliance perspective, the bar keeps getting raised until it feels like we end up spending half our time making sure we are compliant rather than growing our business.

Cathy Beardsley ·
profile

WIA Profile: Samantha Beatrice

Beatrice credits the sex positivity of Montreal for ultimately inspiring her to pursue work in adult entertainment. She had many friends working in the industry, from sex workers to production teams, so it felt like a natural fit and offered an opportunity to apply her marketing and social media savvy to support people she truly believes in and wants to see succeed.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

Understanding the Latest Server Processors

Over the last decade, we mostly stopped talking about CPU performance. Recently, however, there has been a seismic and exciting change in the CPU landscape, due to innovation by a chip company called Advanced Micro Devices (AMD).

Brad Mitchell ·
Show More