opinion

Register Copyrights Sooner Rather Than Later

Register Copyrights Sooner Rather Than Later

Earlier this year, in March, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a decision in the case of Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corp. v. Wall-Street.com, LLC. The ruling affects how copyright infringement is handled generally, including in porn and camming.

Copyright protects works of a creative nature, such as pornographic movies, clips and images, as well as erotic audio stories, written content and more. Typically, copyright vests in the person or persons who authored the work. In some cases, it will vest in a company or third party by virtue of creation by an employee, or when there is a contract with particular, relevant provisions.

Currently, it’s taking an average of seven months for the U.S. Copyright Office to process copyright applications.

A copyright gives its owner several exclusive rights, some of which include the right to reproduce the work, the right to create derivative works (i.e. modified works), the right to publicly display the work and the right to publicly perform the work.

Copyright infringement occurs when someone exercises one of the rights of a copyright holder without the copyright holder’s consent. For instance, it’s likely an infringement when a company creates a great new porn movie, and a third party uploads a copy of that movie to a tube site, or even to Facebook, without a license (i.e. permission). There, the third party has illegally made a copy of the work.

If you’re “in the biz,” you know that copyright infringement is abounding in the world of porn. You also probably know that the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) can be used to facilitate a website service provider’s removal of content illegally uploaded by a third party. The DMCA, however, does not cover when the website provider, itself, uploads the content. For example, the DMCA does not apply when a website operator uploads to its website content of third parties for its own gain, whether it be that they sell subscriptions, VOD or just let it be viewed for free. These kinds of instances, or in cases where content was not removed in response to a proper DMCA notice, must typically be dealt with via a lawsuit.

Currently, it’s taking an average of seven months for the U.S. Copyright Office to process copyright applications. Accordingly, there is a waiting period between the time of the application and the time of registration. The question in the Fourth Estate case was whether the law requires a copyright owner to wait for the registration to issue before bringing suit, or can bring suit in the interim after an application has been filed.

Although one does not need a registration to be the owner of a copyright (as “common law” copyright vests at the time of creation of the work), a registration provides many important benefits, so it is ideal to have registrations for your content. Some of the several benefits include the right to sue in federal court (instead of state court) and increased damage awards in what is called statutory damages.

In Fourth Estate, the Court determined that the law requires an issued registration as a prerequisite to bringing suit — a pending application is not enough. The Court also held that once the registration issues, the copyright owner can recover damages for infringement that occurred both after and before the registration. This means that one must wait until a registration issues to sue, but will then be able to recoup damages from during the waiting period (as well as after).

The effect of the decision is that it is advisable for companies, performers or whoever else is entitled to copyright in content, to file with the Copyright Office as soon as possible. You’ll need to wait until the registration issues, which could take the average of seven months or more, to bring suit in the case of piracy. Though technically you’ll be able to collect damages from the time of application, the success of actually collecting such damages, in many cases where the defendant is insolvent or offshore, might be tenuous. So, file early…

Notwithstanding, the Court did point out some applicable exceptions written into the law. For example, a copyright owner who is preparing to distribute a work of a type vulnerable to predistribution infringement may apply to the Copyright Office for a pre-registration. This exception could apply to porn movies that are high profile before release.

Another example exception discussed by the Court is that a copyright owner may sue for infringement of a live broadcast before copyright has been made. This exception could apply to cam sites where a viewer surreptitiously records the show and then distributes it.

Accordingly, although there are some exceptions that the adult industry should be aware of, in general, the rule of thumb should be — file as soon as possible once the work is completed. Like they say about condoms, “it’s better to be safe than sorry.” Even if you may fall into one of the exceptions, there can only be benefits to filing copyright applications sooner rather than later.

Disclaimer: The content of this article constitutes general information, and is not legal advice. If you would like legal advice from Maxine Lynn, an attorney-client relationship must be formed by signing a letter of engagement with her law firm. To inquire, visit SexTech.Lawyer.

Maxine Lynn is an intellectual property (IP) attorney with the law firm of Keohane & D’Alessandro, PLLC, having offices in Albany, New York, USA. She focuses her practice on prosecution of patents for technology, trademarks for business brands and copyrights for creative materials. Through her company, Unzipped Media, Inc., she publishes the Unzipped: Sex, Tech & the Law blog at SexTechLaw.com and the Unzipped: The Business of Sex podcast at BusinessOf.Sex.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

profile

VerifyMy Seeks to Provide Frictionless Online Safety, Compliance Solutions

Before founding VerifyMy, Ryan Shaw was simply looking for an age verification solution for his previous business. The ones he found, however, were too expensive, too difficult to integrate with, or failed to take into account the needs of either the businesses implementing them or the end users who would be required to interact with them.

Alejandro Freixes ·
opinion

How Adult Website Operators Can Cash in on the 'Interchange' Class Action

The Payment Card Interchange Fee Settlement resulted from a landmark antitrust lawsuit involving Visa, Mastercard and several major banks. The case centered around the interchange fees charged to merchants for processing credit and debit card transactions. These fees are set by card networks and are paid by merchants to the banks that issue the cards.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

It's Time to Rock the Vote and Make Your Voice Heard

When I worked to defeat California’s Proposition 60 in 2016, our opposition campaign was outspent nearly 10 to 1. Nevertheless, our community came together and garnered enough support and awareness to defeat that harmful, misguided piece of proposed legislation — by more than a million votes.

Siouxsie Q ·
opinion

Staying Compliant to Avoid the Takedown Shakedown

Dealing with complaints is an everyday part of doing business — and a crucial one, since not dealing with them properly can haunt your business in multiple ways. Card brand regulations require every merchant doing business online to have in place a complaint process for reporting content that may be illegal or that violates the card brand rules.

Cathy Beardsley ·
profile

WIA Profile: Patricia Ucros

Born in Bogota, Colombia, Ucros graduated from college with a degree in education. She spent three years teaching third grade, which she enjoyed a lot, before heeding her father’s advice and moving to South Florida.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

Creating Payment Redundancies to Maximize Payout Uptime

During the global CrowdStrike outage that took place toward the end of July, a flawed software update brought air travel and electronic commerce to a grinding halt worldwide. This dramatically underscores the importance of having a backup plan in place for critical infrastructure.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

The Need for Minimal Friction in Age Verification Technology

In the adult sector, robust age assurance, comprised of age verification and age estimation methods, is critical to ensuring legal compliance with ever-evolving regulations, safeguarding minors from inappropriate content and protecting the privacy of adults wishing to view adult content.

Gavin Worrall ·
opinion

Account-to-Account Payments: The New Banking Disruptor?

So much of our industry relies upon Visa and Mastercard to support consumer payments — and with that reliance comes increased scrutiny by both brands. From a compliance perspective, the bar keeps getting raised until it feels like we end up spending half our time making sure we are compliant rather than growing our business.

Cathy Beardsley ·
profile

WIA Profile: Samantha Beatrice

Beatrice credits the sex positivity of Montreal for ultimately inspiring her to pursue work in adult entertainment. She had many friends working in the industry, from sex workers to production teams, so it felt like a natural fit and offered an opportunity to apply her marketing and social media savvy to support people she truly believes in and wants to see succeed.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

Understanding the Latest Server Processors

Over the last decade, we mostly stopped talking about CPU performance. Recently, however, there has been a seismic and exciting change in the CPU landscape, due to innovation by a chip company called Advanced Micro Devices (AMD).

Brad Mitchell ·
Show More